Above: Jennifer Fay in 1989 (left) and an age-progressed image to 46 (circa 2018)
Jennifer Lynn Fay
Last seen in Brockton, Massachusetts on November 14, 1989
Vital statistics: White female. Born on December 25, 1972. Blond hair, blue eyes. She has a scar over her eyebrow and her teeth are crowded. Last seen wearing a black silk jacket with an Iron Maiden patch, a purple blouse, blue jeans, and white sneakers. Was sixteen at the time.
Circumstances: Fay was last seen leaving her home. She was supposed to be baby-sitting, but instead went to a friend's. There was a party there and she left around nine PM. She has not been seen since. Classified as a Non-Family Abduction.
Theories: I think Jennifer ran away initially (she was a rebellious teen according to accounts) and became a victim of foul play at some later time. I am skeptical of reports that foul play happened the day of disappearance at the hands of an acquaintance because they have come long after the fact and with few details. In this case, her remains could be anywhere across the country, so a search of unidentifed victims around her age may lead us to Fay.
If you have any information on Fay's whereabouts, please e-mail For the Lost at this address. Or you may contact the Brockton Police Department at 508-941-0200. All tips sent by e-mail will be kept confidential.
Information used to compile this case file comes from the following resources:
The National Center For Missing and Exploited Children
The Doe Network
The Charley Project
The Brockton Enterprise
Where is Jennifer Fay?
Child Quest International
NamUs National Missing Persons Data System
Back to the case files